Wednesday, November 7, 2007

India small loans: drying up ?

ICICI Bank is said to be withdrawing from lending small amounts (up to Rs 30,000) to sub-prime customers in India. This is seen as a response to press reports and judicial action regarding excesses their loan recovery agents have engaged in. ICICI is reported to have closed down 100 outlets focused on such small borrowers.

Citibank has also tightened its processes for lending small amounts. It requires face to face interaction for every potential customer and a rigorous analysis of cash flow. They suggest that customers should ensure that monthly instalments on loans should not exceed 70 to 80% of their surplus income.

There has been a buzz recently about micro finance in India and how it can bring about financial inclusion. However, current 30% loan loss ratio in small loans is seeing fair amount of panic in the sub prime lending market. Coming back to first principles - a bank/finance company should lend money to only those who show strong signs of being able to pay back. Your local money lender knows that. If he is unsure, he knows how to extract the money - a process that is not easily transferable to the formal sector !

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

ICICI Bank fined for loan recovery lapse

ICICI Bank in India has been fined Rs 50 lakhs for employing 'goons' to recover loans.

Press Trust of India reports that the Delhi Consumer Commission fined one of India's leading banks, ICICI Bank Rs 50 lakhs for employing 'goons' to recover loans. The commission also deplored the intimidation tactics that ICICI's recovery agents were using on retail customers. In a recent case, some agents beat up a consumer mercilessly and snatched his car (against which there was the loan) away. The commission has issued notices to the Collection Manager ICICI and the CEO of the recovery agency.

Meanwhile, ICICI is said to have started a process to help prevent such incidents in the future.

Labels: , ,

Friday, November 2, 2007

SBI lowers deposit rates: the opportunity is gone !

State Bank of India (SBI) has finally succumbed to competitive and margin pressures and lowered its interest rates on fixed deposits. It has lowered its peak interest rate on the 550 day deposit by 25 bp to 8.75% from 9 November. More importantly, it has withdrawn its super - saver term deposit scheme carrying a 9% interest rate for deposit maturity of 4 to 5 years and 8.5% for over 5 years.

Revised rates wef 7 November 2007 are:

15-45 days: 5.00%
46-270 days: 5.50%
271 days to less than 1 year: 6.75%
1 year to 549 days: 8.00%
550 days: 8.75%
551 days to less than 2 years: 8.00%
2 years to less than 3 years: 8.25%
3 years and up to 10 years: 8.50%.

This move shuts the door on the opportunity of leveraging lowering property (home loan) interest rates from HDFC while gaining from relatively high deposit interest rates from SBI. Good things don't last that long !

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

India property loan rates: ICICI, HDFC differ in views

ICICI Bank and HDFC appear to differ on the potential impact of higher CRR (Cash Reserve Ratio) on India property loan rates.

Reserve Bank of India (RBI) announced yesterday that banks will have to increase Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) by 50 bp (0.5%), effective from Novermber 10. This means that banks will have to keep this additional percentage of their deposits as non-interest earning amount with the RBI. This is expected to further reduce the amount available for lending.

However, leading banks seem to differ on whether this CRR hike will lead to higher property loan rates. ICICI Bank Joint MD, Ms. Chanda Kochhar feels that this amount of CRR hike can be absorbed and there should be no need for an immediate increase in property loan interest rates. On the other hand, she also clarified that the current low rates offered are only for the Diwali festive period and can be expected to revert back to the pre-festive rates after the assigned period.

Mr. Deepak Parekh, Chairman, HDFC, on the other hand mentions that there is enough liquidity in the system and further lowering of property loan rates cannot be ruled out.

Meanwhile, some public sector banks have acknowledged that deposit interest rates will need to fall further for banks to maintain margins. Interestingly, State Bank of India (SBI) seems to continue wanting to acquire larger deposit market share through attractive deposit interest rates.

This difference highlights once again an interesting arbitrage opportunity: consider taking property loans from HDFC and putting deposits with SBI. As both these giants remain keen to preserve/gain market share in different parts of the retail banking business, you as the retail customer may be able to drive a hard bargain if you are in the market for these products.

Labels: , , , , ,

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

NHB Residex: real estate price index in India

The National Housing Bank (NHB) has launched an index that seeks to track real estate price growth in major cities in India. It is intended to be a broad guide to identify real estate price trends in various areas. The index is called NHB Residex and is expected to be calculated every six months. The first data set tracks prices in key cities between 2001 and 2005:

Residex for select cities (source NHB) - Data for 2001/2002/2003/2004/2005

Delhi: 100 106 129 150 201

Mumbai: 100 116 132 149 178

Kolkata: 100 115 129 148 172

Bangalore: 100 133 170 224 275

This data confirms that all key markets showed significant price rise, with Bengaluru (Bangalore) showing the highest growth rate driven by the IT and BPO businesses. The next set of data is expected in early 2008.

Over the last few years, action has also moved to other cities and smaller towns in India. In fact, some leading developers like Mantri Developers (partners with Morgan Stanley Realty) have indicated that growth in Chennai and Hyderabad is expected to be greater than Bangalore in the near future.

Given growth expectations of the Indian economy, investing in real estate would continue to form an important part of an investor's portfolio.

Labels: , ,

Monday, October 15, 2007

Falling home loan rates in India - time to rejoice?

HDFC, ICICI, SBI and other banks have announced lowering of their home loan rates. Some of them have emphasized that this lowering is a 'festival offer' and applicable to new customers applying for variable rate home loans over the Diwali period.

Fixed rates continue to remain high. By itself, this is an interesting issue - if banks believed that interest rates have begun a downward trend, they should have sufficient incentive to lock in customers in to current high fixed rates as opposed to guiding people to variable rates. Variable rates are generally encouraged by banks when interest rates look like they may be going up. Market analysts suggest that this anomaly is due to high liquidity in the market. We remain unsure and think that should banks figure out rates are finally in a downward trend, fixed rates may also start to decline.

Declining home loan rates are generally good news for borrowers. However, do keep in mind the following:

1. Lowering rates in a growing income scenario improves affordability. A galloping Sensex only makes people feel even wealthier. Better affordability has been one of the driving factors of rapid real estate growth and price rise in India over the last few years.

2. A feeling of growing affordability can harden real estate prices and re-ignite demand. Therefore, while rates are going down, your dream home may get more expensive.

3. Lowering of rates are currently valid only for new customers. Rates for existing customers are typically linked to a 'reference rate' by each bank/HFC (housing finance company). These reference rates are generally not reduced that frequently creating a time lag for existing customers to benefit from rate declines.

4. If you are an existing home loan customer, you may want to consider exploring refinancing (balance transfer loan) at the appropriate time. For example, Indian banks and HFCs have an exit clause of 2% of outstanding amount - should your rates be higher than new rates by 2% + costs of setting up new loan (e.g. Rs 5000 or 0.5%), you may want pull out your calculator and have a serious discussion with your banker!

Labels: , , , ,

Friday, October 5, 2007

Buying a house or apartment in India today – what should you worry about ?

Home loan rates in India have started dropping, real estate prices have been soft for 9 or so months – you must be wondering whether this is the right time to buy that house or apartment/flat in India. Here are some thoughts for you to keep in mind:

1. It is recognized that there is a shortage of dwelling units in India. Sustained lowering in interest rates can reignite demand and therefore raise prices again

2. Price softening has happened primarily in outer areas of metros, while prices within the main cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore and Chennai have remained strong. In fact, prices in well known residential areas in these cities are now way higher than what most residents in the city can afford. This has been primarily due to shortage of land in such localities while demand has kept rising with growing wealth disparity in India

3. Outer areas of metros suffer from lack of infrastructure and security making it less attractive for people to live in these locations. Therefore, a significant portion of money that has gone into such locations has been investor money. Such locations are easily hurt by lowering of demand due to interest rate hikes

4. Land titles remain a major issue in India, except in areas approved by local authorities. With large amount of private equity money seeking large land deals, price of large tracts of ‘clean titled’ land and apartments/flats built on them keeps going up. However, unless demand for such properties/complexes in outer areas firm up, one can expect a flattening of prices here

5. Significant number of apartments/flats in such large complexes has been bought by NRIs and investors from outside the city, based on promising brochures. Unless you are able to assess the land and builder quality yourself, you are always at risk of being led astray by these promises.

As ever, the best way to buy property in India is to focus on areas approved by the local authorities and within accessible distance to key city centres. It will be a long time before India has road and metro infrastructure to enable people to live comfortably in more distant suburbs.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, October 3, 2007

Loan recovery business in India - the ugly side

The following report from IBNlive illustrates the scary nature of this evolving business:

" By IBNlive.com

Wednesday October 3, 09:01 AM New Delhi:

Standing tall at 5 ft 11 inches, Lucky is a daunting and an imposing sight on the streets of Delhi. This 38-year-old has just started a detective agency of his own, but that's only a front for his real job. Lucky is a recovery agent. Big private banks hire him to make sure their loans are returned on time. Eighteen years in the business and he knows exactly how to get customers to pay up.

“We threaten people, we land up at their place and sometimes even use third degree,” he admits to CNN-IBN.

Welcome to the world of corporate sponsored violence, a dark underbelly of the swanky banking sector where local goons and ruffians are hired by banks to terrorise customers into settling their dues.

Where threatening calls, verbal abuse and even physical violence have become part of routine collection system.

These recovery agents are not on any bank's rolls but stand to get a hefty cut of booty they help recover.

“Not just lathis, some agents even pull out their mousers, they stop cars on gunpoint, drag the owners and drive away with the car,” Lucky says.

Sixty-year-old Surinder Kumar runs a consultancy in west Delhi. Two months ago, he fell victim to recovery sharks when one of his employees defaulted on his Rs-50,000 credit card payment to HDFC bank.

“He abused, used filthy language and threatened us. They said our kid has been picked up. We were very scared. I wondered if we should stop sending him to school,” he recalls.

Surinder is just one of thousands of people who've seen the ugly side of loan recovery process.

Blame it on over-aspiring consumers who borrow more than they can return or overzealous lenders who then bend the rules to recover their debts, the paranoia continues.

This corporate tactic has also turned deadly with a spate of suicides. Two weeks ago Prakash Sarvankar of Mumbai, harassed by ICICI banks recovery agents, was forced into taking the extreme step.

For the likes of Lucky and others in his league, it’s just another job. “I feel bad about my job. But if I don't do it, someone else will,” he says.

Gandhi may be stamped on the currency banks lend, but there's nothing Gandhian about the way they go about recovering it. "

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

India home loan rates heading downwards

In an earlier post, we mentioned that HDFC was looking to lower home loan rates. They have since announced their revised home loan rates:

1. 'Special' rate of interest of 10.5% for customers availing of floating rate home loans. This is 0.75% lower than HDFC's regular rates

2. This offer is available for all loans disbursed on or before 31 Oct 2007

3. However, interest rate for fixed rate loans is 13.25%.

The wide difference between fixed and floating rates is said to be in place to act as a disincentive for consumers going for fixed rate loans.

Interestingly, Mr. Deepak Parekh, Chairman HDFC mentions in a TV interview that the Finance Minister thought HDFC should go deeper with the interest rate cuts !

Therefore, please continue to watch this space.

Labels:

Monday, September 24, 2007

Interesting opportunity - deposits vs home loans in India

There has been pressure in recent times for Indian banks to lower deposit rates. However, reports suggest that SBI is hesitant to do so as it seeks to continue to grow the deposit business. Therefore, one can still secure around 9% pa interest rates on deposits with SBI. Other banks are seeking to lower deposit interest rates but can't really do so if SBI maintains this position. On the other hand, HDFC is showing signs of lowering home loan rates.

This points to a potential to get best of both worlds by splitting your deposit and home loan relationships, if not done so already. Multi-bank relationships are quite normal and a customer should seek the best product features/deals in all major products - a bank should offer you significant additional value should it want to keep most of your relationship.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

Reverse Mortgages in India: Loan against your home

We were asked to clarify issues surrounding reverse mortgages. Please note that each country will have specific features for the product that need to be understood based on where the property is situated. Our comments are specific to the product in India.

The National Housing Bank (subsidiary of Reserve Bank of India) has described the principles of the product in a presentation dated Feb 2007. The presentation is available at http://www.nhb.org.in/. To summarize, product features are:

1. Senior citizens in India are eligible. Main criteria are that one of the spouses needs to be a senior citizen and house where they live in India needs to have been fully paid up. Income criteria is not to be used for this loan

2. Loan is for a max term of 15 years and will be against the house they currently live in. Typically, the husband and wife will be co-borrowers

3. In this type of loan, a bank or housing finance company (HFC) in India is to grant the loan to the borrowers in either a lump sum or in various instalment modes (e.g. monthly, quarterly, etc)

4. Loan amount will depend on age of main borrower and value of the property

5. Loan can be used for living expenses, renovation of home or other purposes

6. Borrowers do not have to service the loan for the term - i.e. no interest payment or principal repayment is expected for the 15 year term

7. Borrowers are expected to pay back loan principal + accumulated interest at the end of 15 years. Each financial service institution retains the right to set interest rates

8. Should the main borrower die before the 15 year term, his/her spouse can continue to live in the property till either he/she also dies or term is up. Should both spouses die before the end of the 15 year term, the bank or HFC will give the first right to settle the loan to the borrowers' heirs. Should this not be possible, the bank/HFC will sell the property, clear the loan outstanding (principal + interest) and return the balance to the borrower's estate

9. Other events that can trigger a full payment of loan outstanding is the sale of the property by the borrowers or them moving out to live elsewhere

10. The loan can be paid off at any time without any prepayment penalties.

While this product is expected to be valuable to senior citizens who have cash flow problems, main issue is the risk of them outliving the 15 year term. Should this happen, they will have to pay back the loan outstanding. As they took the loan in the first place to bolster cash flow, it is not clear where they will get the money to settle the loan ! Therefore, one needs to exercise care in using this product like any other debt product - unless repayment sources are clear, debt can be a difficult thing !

Labels: ,